| Published Version Download ( PDF | 904kB) | License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 |
The underestimated role of effort in ability self-concept formation: Preliminary evidence for another major comparison process
Article
Debatin, Tobias
, Stoeger, Heidrun
and Ziegler, Albert
(2026)
The underestimated role of effort in ability self-concept formation: Preliminary evidence for another major comparison process.
Learning and Instruction 107, p. 102471.
DOI to cite this document: 10.5283/epub.80764
Abstract
Background Early studies found that, among individuals with equal achievement, those perceived to exert less effort were rated as having greater ability (i.e. there was a negative relationship between effort and ability), leading to proposals that effort-achievement comparisons are highly influential in forming ability self-concepts. We argue that effort-achievement comparisons have been ...
Background
Early studies found that, among individuals with equal achievement, those perceived to exert less effort were rated as having greater ability (i.e. there was a negative relationship between effort and ability), leading to proposals that effort-achievement comparisons are highly influential in forming ability self-concepts. We argue that effort-achievement comparisons have been neglected in recent research due to large-scale studies failing to confirm the early findings. However, this may be because these studies have shifted their focus to a different type of effort: goal-driven effort, meaning perceived effort an individual actively chooses to invest.
Aims
This study examines whether the negative relationship between effort and ability self-concepts among individuals with equal achievement can be confirmed when effort is operationalized more similarly to the earlier studies, as so-called data-driven effort, meaning perceived effort resulting from task requirements.
Sample
Participants were 448 ninth-grade students from Germany.
Method
Data-driven effort, achievements (school grades) and ability self-concepts in the domains of STEM and languages were assessed. We used structural equation modeling to test our hypotheses.
Results
There was a strong negative relationship between data-driven effort and ability self-concepts in the two domains when controlling for achievements in the domains.
Conclusions
In line with older self-concept research, these findings suggest that there is another influential comparison process, in which data-driven effort is compared with achievements, a topic that merits further investigation in future research.
Alternative links to fulltext
Involved Institutions
Details
| Item type | Article | ||||
| Journal or Publication Title | Learning and Instruction | ||||
| Publisher | Elsevier | ||||
| Open Access Type | DEAL (Elsevier) | ||||
| Volume | 107 | ||||
| Page Range | p. 102471 | ||||
| Date | 10 September 2026 | ||||
| Date of publication | 22 Sep 2026 06:52 | ||||
| Institutions | Human Sciences > Institut für Bildungswissenschaft > Lehrstuhl für Schulpädagogik (Prof. Dr. Heidrun Stöger) Human Sciences > Institut für Bildungswissenschaft | ||||
| Projects |
Funded by:
Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung (BMBF)
(16MF1091A)
| ||||
| Identification Number |
| ||||
| Keywords | Academic self-concept, Effort, Dimensional comparisons, Social comparisons, Metacognition | ||||
| Dewey Decimal Classification | 300 Social sciences > 370 Education | ||||
| Status | Published | ||||
| Refereed | Yes, this version has been refereed | ||||
| Created at the University of Regensburg | Partially | ||||
| URN of the UB Regensburg | urn:nbn:de:bvb:355-epub-807642 | ||||
| Item ID | 80764 |
Download Statistics
Download Statistics