Direkt zum Inhalt

Debatin, Tobias ; Stoeger, Heidrun ; Ziegler, Albert

The underestimated role of effort in ability self-concept formation: Preliminary evidence for another major comparison process

Article

Debatin, Tobias , Stoeger, Heidrun and Ziegler, Albert (2026) The underestimated role of effort in ability self-concept formation: Preliminary evidence for another major comparison process. Learning and Instruction 107, p. 102471.

DOI to cite this document: 10.5283/epub.80764


Abstract

Background Early studies found that, among individuals with equal achievement, those perceived to exert less effort were rated as having greater ability (i.e. there was a negative relationship between effort and ability), leading to proposals that effort-achievement comparisons are highly influential in forming ability self-concepts. We argue that effort-achievement comparisons have been ...

Background
Early studies found that, among individuals with equal achievement, those perceived to exert less effort were rated as having greater ability (i.e. there was a negative relationship between effort and ability), leading to proposals that effort-achievement comparisons are highly influential in forming ability self-concepts. We argue that effort-achievement comparisons have been neglected in recent research due to large-scale studies failing to confirm the early findings. However, this may be because these studies have shifted their focus to a different type of effort: goal-driven effort, meaning perceived effort an individual actively chooses to invest.
Aims
This study examines whether the negative relationship between effort and ability self-concepts among individuals with equal achievement can be confirmed when effort is operationalized more similarly to the earlier studies, as so-called data-driven effort, meaning perceived effort resulting from task requirements.
Sample
Participants were 448 ninth-grade students from Germany.
Method
Data-driven effort, achievements (school grades) and ability self-concepts in the domains of STEM and languages were assessed. We used structural equation modeling to test our hypotheses.
Results
There was a strong negative relationship between data-driven effort and ability self-concepts in the two domains when controlling for achievements in the domains.
Conclusions
In line with older self-concept research, these findings suggest that there is another influential comparison process, in which data-driven effort is compared with achievements, a topic that merits further investigation in future research.



Involved Institutions


Details

Item typeArticle
Journal or Publication TitleLearning and Instruction
PublisherElsevier
Open Access TypeDEAL (Elsevier)
Volume107
Page Rangep. 102471
Date10 September 2026
Date of publication22 Sep 2026 06:52
InstitutionsHuman Sciences > Institut für Bildungswissenschaft > Lehrstuhl für Schulpädagogik (Prof. Dr. Heidrun Stöger)
Human Sciences > Institut für Bildungswissenschaft
Projects
Funded by: Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung (BMBF) (16MF1091A)
Identification Number
ValueType
10.1016/j.learninstruc.2026.102471DOI
KeywordsAcademic self-concept, Effort, Dimensional comparisons, Social comparisons, Metacognition
Dewey Decimal Classification300 Social sciences > 370 Education
StatusPublished
RefereedYes, this version has been refereed
Created at the University of RegensburgPartially
URN of the UB Regensburgurn:nbn:de:bvb:355-epub-807642
Item ID80764

Export bibliographical data

Owner only: item control page

nach oben