Direkt zum Inhalt

Suggate, Sebastian P. ; Schmalenbach, Bernhard ; Peters, Jürgen

A Meta-Analysis of Outcomes for Steiner/Waldorf and Mainstream Education

Artikel

Suggate, Sebastian P. , Schmalenbach, Bernhard und Peters, Jürgen (2026) A Meta-Analysis of Outcomes for Steiner/Waldorf and Mainstream Education. Review of Educational Research.

DOI zum Zitieren dieses Dokuments: 10.5283/epub.83193


Zusammenfassung

Despite being over 100 years old, empirical research on Waldorf (or Steiner) education has been scarce, with no published meta-analyses comparing outcomes to mainstream education. We identified 30 studies comparing outcomes for Waldorf (N = 7,823) and mainstream (N = 187,015) students, netting 40 treatment-control comparisons and 506 effect sizes, from 11 countries. Mixed-effects meta-regressions ...

Despite being over 100 years old, empirical research on Waldorf (or Steiner) education has been scarce, with no published meta-analyses comparing outcomes to mainstream education. We identified 30 studies comparing outcomes for Waldorf (N = 7,823) and mainstream (N = 187,015) students, netting 40 treatment-control comparisons and 506 effect sizes, from 11 countries. Mixed-effects meta-regressions investigated the role of measurement, publication, sample features, and outcome (i.e., academic achievement, creativity, attitudes and emotions, school and classroom climate, and moral development). Overall, Waldorf students performed significantly better (d = .216, after trim-and-fill, d = .369). Waldorf students had significantly greater academic achievement and reported a significantly better school and classroom climate, with differences in aesthetic creativity, attitudes and emotions, and moral development not being statistically significant. Given the comparative designs employed, further research using quasi-experimental and longitudinal designs is needed, both on the domains investigated here and further domains.



Beteiligte Einrichtungen


Details

DokumentenartArtikel
Titel eines Journals oder einer ZeitschriftReview of Educational Research
VerlagSage
Open Access ArtSAGE (Hybrid)
Datum11 November 2026
Veröffentlichungsdatum17 Nov 2026 14:10
InstitutionenHumanwissenschaften > Institut für Bildungswissenschaft > Lehrstuhl für Schulpädagogik (Prof. Dr. Heidrun Stöger)
Humanwissenschaften > Institut für Bildungswissenschaft
Identifikationsnummer
WertTyp
10.3102/00346543261495960DOI
Stichwörter / Keywordsachievement, moral education/development, educational reform, classroom research, attitude, meta-analysis, quasi-experimental analysis, Waldorf education, Steiner education, academic skills, creativity, classroom climate, moral development, aesthetics, drawing
Dewey-Dezimal-Klassifikation300 Sozialwissenschaften > 370 Erziehung, Schul- und Bildungswesen
StatusVeröffentlicht
BegutachtetJa, diese Version wurde begutachtet
An der Universität Regensburg entstandenJa
URN der UB Regensburgurn:nbn:de:bvb:355-epub-831938
Dokumenten-ID83193

Bibliographische Daten exportieren

Nur für Besitzer und Autoren: Kontrollseite des Eintrags

nach oben